While the Caribbean remains a prime destination for global travelers, certain islands in the region pose heightened risks due to crime and other safety concerns.
In 2025, five islands stand out for their potential dangers, as indicated by U.S. travel advisories and recent incidents.
Here’s a closer look at these destinations, their specific risks, and the areas most affected.
6. Cuba
Current U.S. Travel Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
As of November 22, 2024, the U.S. Department of State has issued a Level 2 travel advisory for Cuba, advising travelers to exercise increased caution due to crime. Tourists are susceptible to petty crimes such as pickpocketing, purse snatching, and car break-ins. Incidents of violent crime, including armed robbery and homicide, have also been reported.
While the voluntary departure of non-emergency U.S. personnel was lifted on November 21, 2024, following Hurricane Rafael’s aftermath, travel outside Havana for U.S. Embassy employees requires special notification, potentially limiting emergency assistance capabilities for U.S. citizens. Travelers are advised to remain vigilant, avoid displaying signs of wealth.
Additionally, U.S. credit and debit cards do not function in Cuba; visitors should bring sufficient cash and exchange it for Cuban Pesos (CUP) at authorized institutions.
5. Dominican Republic
Current U.S. Travel Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
The Dominican Republic combines natural beauty with significant risks. Crime hotspots include Santo Domingo and Santiago. Common issues range from pickpocketing to more severe crimes such as armed robbery and assault, especially in poorly lit or secluded areas.
The main tourist hotspot, Punta Cana is generally safe but some pickpocketing might occur.
In recent years, incidents of counterfeit alcohol poisoning and scams targeting tourists have added to safety concerns. The U.S. government advises travelers to use organized tours and avoid solo nighttime excursions.
4. The Bahamas
Current U.S. Travel Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
The Bahamas is a favored destination, but its crime rates warrant caution. The capital, Nassau, sees the most incidents, with violent crimes such as armed robbery, sexual assault, and home invasions frequently reported.
According to data from early 2024, the country recorded a startling 128 murders, many linked to gang violence and drug trafficking. Tourists are advised to avoid “Over-the-Hill” neighborhoods and be vigilant even in tourist-heavy areas like Cable Beach.
3. Jamaica
Current U.S. Travel Advisory: Level 3 – Reconsider Travel
Jamaica remains a popular destination despite its enduring challenges with crime. Last year, the U.S. government issued multiple advisories highlighting risks, particularly in Kingston, Montego Bay, and Spanish Town, where gang-related violence, shootings, and carjackings are prevalent.
Tourists staying at resorts are generally safer, but venturing outside gated communities requires extra caution. The nation’s inability to curb crime effectively in 2024 has continued to fuel safety concerns in 2025.
2. Trinidad and Tobago
Current U.S. Travel Advisory: Level 3 – Exercise Increased Caution
Trinidad and Tobago’s crime issues are particularly concentrated in Trinidad, with hotspots including Port of Spain, Laventille, and St. James. Violent crimes such as murder, robbery, and kidnappings are the primary concerns, with many linked to gang activities and narcotics.
According to the latest news from December 30, the local government in Trinidad and Tobago declared a State of Emergency over the exceptionally deadly year 2024.
Tourists in Tobago face lower risks, though theft and property crimes occur. Recent reports in early 2025 have noted an uptick in petty crimes targeting tourists during Carnival, urging heightened vigilance.
1. Haiti
Current U.S. Travel Advisory: Level 4 – Do Not Travel
Haiti continues to grapple with severe political instability, gang violence, and natural disasters. Kidnappings have surged alarmingly, with armed gangs targeting both locals and foreign nationals in Port-au-Prince and other urban areas. Violent protests, frequent roadblocks, and limited access to emergency services exacerbate the situation. The U.S. government strongly advises against all non-essential travel to Haiti due to these pervasive risks.
Safety Travel Tips for 2025
While these islands pose significant risks, proper precautions can minimize dangers. Tourists should:
- Stay informed through updated U.S. travel advisories.
- Avoid high-crime areas, especially after dark.
- Use reputable transportation services.
- Refrain from displaying valuables or large amounts of cash.
The Caribbean remains a captivating destination, but understanding potential risks and exercising prudence is essential for safe travels in 2025.